Consider the costs of ethanol
A couple of recent newsletters from Sen. Tom Harkin define a tricky intersection that Iowa is now approaching.
In one, Harkin extols the virtues of the Conservation Security Program, which is the government’s effort to take cropland out of production and increase wildlife habitat at the same time.”I am committed to expanding the program to every part of our state so that every farmer has the opportunity to enroll,” Harkin wrote.”This will help to improve water quality and wildlife habitat for all Iowans.”
Sounds good.But then there’s ethanol.
Harkin is chairman of the Senate Agriculture, Nutrition and Forestry Committee, which puts him in the middle of writing the next farm bill. “As chairman … I intend to use the new farm bill as the vehicle for a dramatic ramping up of the production, distribution and consumption of biofuels and other forms of renewable energy,” he said in the other newsletter.
Another admirable goal in terms of Iowa’s economic fortunes.
But when we start to get serious about increasing our corn and soybean crops, that conservation ground is going to look awfully tempting.
If we start driving into those grassy areas with herbicides and chisel plows, it’s not just the pheasant hunters who will be affected. We’ll start eating into our stockpile of topsoil faster than ever.
And if we throw every available kernel into ethanol production, it won’t be just the tortilla buyers in Mexico who are affected by the increase in prices. First the livestock farmers will notice that feed is getting more expensive, then the non-farmers will notice the same about food for the dinner table.
We’re committed to building an ethanol industry, so let’s be aggressive. But the path seems to wind through a lot of problematic consequences, so let’s keep looking for better routes.
Based on what we know so far, it seems wise to put a substantial amount of time and money into studying the cellulosic ethanol possibilities. Environmentally and maybe economically, switchgrass and the like might be a better bet than corn.