Contractors’ safety records beat national trend
Working in an environment where every project, every task and every crew changes daily may help explain why construction is one of the most dangerous industries.
But in recent years, some construction companies have started to address the industry’s alarmingly poor safety record by being proactive about preventing hazardous situations and making safety as high a priority as budget and time. And they have seen considerable results from those efforts.
Story Construction Co. in Ames, for example, has recorded 1.41 million man-hours without a lost-time injury since Jan. 15, 2003, with an average work force of 170 employees. Weitz Iowa just achieved 1 million man-hours without a lost-time injury since February 2005, with an average roster of around 250 employees.
“That is an incredible achievement given the nature of this industry,” said Greg Spenner, president and CEO of the Iowa chapter of Associated Builders and Contractors Inc., which has nearly 400 members.
The results are far from the industry trends.
Of the 5,702 fatal work injuries in the United States in 2005, the construction industry accounted for 1,186, the most of any industry. Although the figures were down slightly from 1,234 fatalities in 2004, James Schaack, a safety manager for The Weitz Co., said the fatality number tends to be around 1,000 to 1,200 every year.
In addition, 2.5 of every 100 fulltime construction workers in the United States in 2005 had a lost-time injury, an injury that causes an employee to miss more than a day from work. Iowa’s rate was 3.2.
“The fact that our industry does not have a very stellar record when it comes to keeping people safe,we’re not very proud of that as a company,” said Mike Tousley, president of Weitz Iowa.
“Safety is one of our core values,”said Mark Wieland, safety coordinator for Story Construction. “If we’re safe on a job site, we spend less time investigating injures and retraining and more time on production and quality. Safety is an integral part of the operations versus just a thing we have to do.”
Jens Nissen, executive officer of Iowa Workforce Development’s occupational safety and health enforcement division, said although people continue to die in the workplace, the figures today are much lower than in the 1970s, when President Richard Nixon signed the bill to create the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration. “Overall, people are getting the message,” he said.
Still, he said, the top four hazards in construction continue to be falls, electrocution, caught in something and struck by something.
Proactive vs. reactive
Companies are moving away from punishing employees for unsafe actions to working with them to avoid hazards, said Spenner.
“It’s both an employer and employee situation,” he said, with the employer providing the training and safety equipment and the employee making an effort to be more aware of hazards.
To facilitate this effort, many larger contractors have at least one full-time employee focused on safety.
In the late 1990s, Story Construction hired its first safety coordinator, Wieland said. The Weitz Co. had only one safety manager a decade ago, Schaack said, but now it has eight, with certain safety managers focusing on one unit within the company.The company might hire two more.
For smaller companies that cannot afford a safety manager, associations like ABC provide one.”More and more companies on a daily basis recognize the importance of having safety directors or a person responsible for safety in the company and are moving to that,” Spenner said. “Those firms that simply can’t do that rely on associations like ours to be able to provide them that resource.”
As a safety manager, Schaack said he is involved in all aspects of a project. Each team is required to meet with him prior to starting a project to talk about potential safety problems and the cost to properly equip the site. Pre-project planning even goes into details such as whether there are enough fire extinguishers on the job site, he said.
Not only does every project have a specific safety plan, but most companies also have started having each crew hold a short meeting at the beginning of the day to talk about what tasks are ahead and what hazards may exist, Spenner said.
Safety managers also train employees on new equipment, provide expertise on potential safety issues, audit job sites and look at statistics to find areas of improvement. If an incident occurs, safety managers will help investigate the incident to determine what happened. Some even share the report with the entire company, so that others can learn from the mistake.
Building a strong safety record starts with a willingness at the executive level to put extra time and resources into safety planning, people in the business say.
The Weitz Co. hosted a two-day safety “boot camp” in December, which brought all the executives from its 10 units together to heighten the management’s commitment to safety. Tousley said, “One of the things that came out pretty loud and clear is that safety is every bit as important on our projects as budget and schedule.” Weitz Iowa then hosted a similar boot camp for 140 of its staff.
Industry-wide attention
In addition to a heightened awareness of safety issues, construction equipment continues to improve.
“By far the industry itself is changing,” Schaack said.”It’s recognizing continuous problems. It’s coming out with new and better equipment, anything from a concrete buggy that you ride on instead of walk behind to a laser-operated screen that helps finish concrete in place of three or four individuals, reducing the amount of stress [on workers].”
Wieland agreed and said it often involves recognizing potential hazards and finding ways to avoid them. This year, Story Construction is focusing on ways to reduce face and eye injuries after a number of its workers suffered such injuries.Weitz Iowa noticed there were a lot of sprains and strains on its job sites and has consequently implemented a program of stretching exercises each morning.
To facilitate changes, companies have become more willing to share ideas with other contractors about their safety plans,Wieland and Spenner said.
“One big thing that has probably changed over the last 10 years is that if I wrote a safety plan, I held it to my chest. Now I call any colleagues,” Wieland said.
ABC has a safety committee that brings safety directors together monthly to share information, and general contractors will work with subcontractors on safety issues.
Weitz especially has taken an active role in working with subcontractors. For example, a few weeks ago, it brought in all the electrical subcontractors it works with to talk about the company’s expectations when working on energized circuits
“It’s an obligation taken pretty seriously because we are responsible for what happens on our sites,” Tousley said. “Subcontractor work is by far a large percentage of work that gets done on our site.”
Many construction companies also have worked cooperatively with Iowa Workforce Development’s enforcement division. ABC used to have a partnership with the agency, which encouraged government officials to work with companies rather than penalize them. New federal regulations caused the partnership to dissolve, but Spenner said ABC is working on a similar alliance program.
Although safety is becoming part of many companies’ culture, it hasn’t resulted in a drastic reduction of incidents.
“The sad reality is in the U.S., three construction workers who go to work in the morning don’t return home to their families that day,” Spenner said. “Every construction trade association, every contractor is working to take that number down. Construction is a dangerous job, but proper tools, proper training and making sure employees are aware of their surroundings have contributed to fewer accidents on the job site.”

