The right tax at the right time
If good sense and an appreciation for timing prevail in the Iowa Legislature, this is the last time we’ll have to take this particular editorial position: Raise the cigarette tax. Gov. Chet Culver’s call for a dollar-a-pack increase is more ambitious than the proposal by his predecessor, but it’s not out of line, and the fact that the additional $130 million it is projected to raise annually would be earmarked for health-care initiatives makes it the right tax at the right time.
It’s true that Culver campaigned on a promise not to raise taxes.A valuable lesson in that is that politicians should learn to never say never. Another one is that sometimes opportunities arise that shouldn’t be avoided, regardless of what was said when the political landscape looked so dramatically different than it does now with Democrats in control of the legislative and executive branches of Iowa government.
It would be hard to create more favorable conditions in which to pass socially relevant legislation. For the first time in recent memory, Iowa lawmakers have a genuine opportunity to make the state more progressive and attractive to the legions of young people we’d like to persuade to come here and work.
There are a host of proposals, from stem-cell research initiatives to anti-bullying legislation to increasing the cigarette tax to $1.36 per pack, that are politically charged, but which we believe can move Iowa light-years ahead socially. Such proposals don’t have much chance of moving forward when more conservative-leaning politicians controlled the Statehouse.
Iowans don’t like tax increases. No one does. However, the proposal to hike tobacco taxes carries benefits that affect far more than a line item on a budget.As much as Iowans may dislike tax increases, they don’t care much for spiraling health-care costs, either, or the disturbing number of young people who take up the deadly smoking habit each year.
In the meantime, Culver needs to learn the valuable lesson that he should talk about the direction Iowa should be heading, but avoid making promises that are difficult to keep.
editor@bpcdm.com